Famous Autographs

Welcome

December 13th, 2008

Civil War
Civil War
Civil war???

I am doing a report on the civil war and i need to know EVERYTHING!!! What were both sides about, which side are you on and why, and tell me everything i will need to know or give me a website

1. True, the original focus of the war was NOT on slavery. But anyone who tries to argue that slavery was dying out or that slavery was not a huge factor in driving the war is engaging in revisionist history:
–the States Rights argument (which was a huge focus issue for many seccesionists) was in part about slavery, the argument that future states added to the US should be slave states or should not be banned from holding slaves.
–look up “Bleeding Kansas”. Right before the civil war started, that bloodshed between the Bushwackers and Jayhawkers was completely about slavery.
–Yep, slavery had been abolished in Europe. But the number of slaves (as total numbers in the population) grew every year in the South from 1845-1860. Slavery was GROWING, not dying away. And the richest individuals in the south and the prime industries (cotton and tobacco) were dependent on slavery at that time.

2. Wow, the claim that the South had the best soldiers, the best shots, inflicted significantly more casualties, the best generals and the worst camp was in the North…again, that’s a bit over the top.
–The South lost or drew every single major battle in the Western Theater in 4 years of war except for Chickamauga. That’s a stunning record of military incompetence. Throughout the war in the over 300 military engagements of consequence, the North won 2/3rds of them. Make a list of great Southern Army or Corps commanders and you come up with Cleburne, Lee and Jackson (maybe Longstreet–though he was unimpressive in the West). Make a list of impressive Union Army commanders and you’d have: Grant, Thomas, Sheridan, Sherman, Meade, Hancock, Sedgwick, and Reynolds (peers who knew them both regarded John Reynolds as Lee’s equal). Look at it this way, the South couldn’t replace Jackson, Cleburne, Turner Ashby or Jeb Stuart when they died but the North had no problem replacing Sedgwick, Reynolds, Richardson or other good senior officers. That’s because they had a lot more good officers than the Confederacy did. As for casualties, Union battlefield deaths came to about 110,070. Confederate battlefield deaths came to about 94,000. That’s not much of a difference in total numbers. As for your claim that Southerners were better shots, the reality is that the Union (because of industry) had more rifled guns (with too many Southern boys depended on their own smoothbore muskets they brought from home). Accurate killing range of a smoothbore muzzle loader would be about 100 yards (48 of 50 shots in a test at the time) but at 200 yards only 24 of 50 and at 300 yards only 7 out of 50 shots. Using a rifled musket on the same range with the same marksmen the results were….50 of 50 at 100 yards, 41 of 50 at 200 yards (double the muzzleloader accuracy), 29 of 50 at 300 yards (4x the accuracy of a muzzleloader) and 7 of 50 at 500 yards (the smoothbores made no attempt to fire at 400 or 500 yards). Well, the Union (because of industry and better supplies) had far more rifled muskets and were far more accurate and at greater distances too.

3. Camp Douglas vs. Andersonville. Yes, both were terrible prisons and the records for BOTH sides during the war was terrible. Camp administration at both camps was inexcusable and criminal. More than 6,000 Confederates died at Camp Douglas. 26,000 were held there (80 acres of ground) but the most at one time was 12,000. More than 13,000 Union prisoners died at Andersonville with as many as 32,000 crowded into the camp at one time (26 acres of ground). Additionally, while both sides did some terrible things, the Confederal execution of prisoners (because they were black) at the Crater and Ft. Sill is also embarassing, especially for those who want to argue that the only reason slavery came up was due to manipulation by Lincoln.

4. A very quick summary of the war:
–The southern states seceded. Forces fired on Union troops at Ft. Sumter in Charleston SC harbor. Newly elected US President Lincoln insisted that he would crush the rebellion and force the Southern states back into the Union.
–In the East, the initial conflicts were mixed with the South nearly losing First Manassas (until troops arrived by train to turn the day and make it a rout). Other early battles led to Confederate losses until Joe Johnston was replaced by E.C. Smith who was then replaced by Robert E. Lee. That led to a series of Confederate defensive successes in the East. In the West, the Confederacy failed at all strategic efforts. The Union engaged in a strategy of blockading the South (so they couldn’t trade) and succeeded at this. They also adopted a strategy of cutting the South in half (by seizing the Mississippi river)–a strategy that would prove successful and doom the Confederacy. The ineptitude of the Confederate Navy and their inability to defend the Mississippi cost the South the war.

Every time the Confederates tried to go on the offense, they failed either tactically, strategically or both. Shiloh led to massive casualties, a strategic failure and a retreat. Stones River led to the loss of vital agricultural support and two states. Antietam failed to gain any new recruits from Maryland and virtually destroyed Lee’s two best units: the Stonewall Brigade and the 1st Texas Brigade. After Gettysburg the South was incapable of offensive warfare any longer. Think of it this way: in the West, the major Southern offensives were at Shiloh and Stone’s River and both led to defeats and withdrawals with loss of critical territory while failing to accomplish the initial objectives. In the East, Lee’s two offensives were Antietam and Gettysburg. Both failed to accomplish their objectives and both crippled his army in terms of casualties (manpower and generalship).

In the West, the Union was dominate, pretty much running the table against the Confederacy. Vicksburg was probably the single most important battle of the Civil War–once Vicksburg fell, the Union controlled the Mississipi which meant that moving troops and supplies was nearly impossible for the South. In the East, once generals such as Hancock and Meade gained more responsibility, the South started to have problems. When Grant was shifted East, Lee was forced to basically fight just to buy time–trading lives for a few more weeks or a month–the end was pretty much never in doubt at that point.

Grant began to seek out Lee and destroy his army. In a series of engagements in the East, Grant continued to try and circle Lee or beat him to a crucial crossroads in order to get to Richmond. Lee was forced to play reactively and in a totally defensive role. In the West, Sherman led his army through the South, into Georgia and then cut to the East Coast and headed North through the Carolinas, anhialiating every force he faced. Grant continued to stretch his lines knowing that Lee didn’t have the manpower to match him. Eventually, Lee conceeded Richmond (so the South’s capital fell to the North) and tried to manuever away from Grant but failed, surrendering his forces at Appomattax Court House in Virginia, effectively ending the Civil War (fighting continued but it was inconsequential in terms of impact or numbers of casualties).

With hindsight, it’s amazing that the Confederacy ever thought they had a chance. They failed to win a single naval engagement during the war. The Union consistently had more and better artillery that was better organized (and this played a decisive role at the 3rd day of Gettysburg, Shiloh and Stones River–probably deciding all 3 battles). They inherited more outstanding officers from the regular army. They had more industry, more people, more agriculture (south produced more cotton and tobacco but the north produced more fruit, corn, wheat, cattle and horses), infrastructure (so supplies were always a problem). Plus after 2 years of fighting, the Union suddenly added 200,000 fresh and highly motivated soldiers (the US Colored Infantry). By the end of the war, every major Confederate city and industrial center had fallen. Every competent or outstanding Confederate senior officer other than Lee had been killed or wounded. As noted historian (and MIssissipi native) Shelby Foote liked to say, the North fought the entire war with one hand behind their back.

eBay Logo  

GI JOE IDW #3 CVR A GI JOE COBRA CIVIL WAR NEW RARE


GI JOE IDW #3 CVR A GI JOE COBRA CIVIL WAR NEW RARE


£1.99


US Civil war General J E B Stuart new King Queen madagascar 1863 old prints


US Civil war General J E B Stuart new King Queen madagascar 1863 old prints


£6.99


BRITAINS AMERICAN CIVIL WAR FIGURES CONFEDERATES DEETAIL


BRITAINS AMERICAN CIVIL WAR FIGURES CONFEDERATES DEETAIL


£6.80


28mm Spanish Civil War - Pro-Painted


28mm Spanish Civil War – Pro-Painted


£12.00


Viewbook, U.S. Grant Album 1886 Life Of Civil War  General U.S. Grant  Pictures


Viewbook, U.S. Grant Album 1886 Life Of Civil War General U.S. Grant Pictures


£17.64


The Civil War in Stratford-Upon-Avon: Conflict and Community in South Warwicksh


The Civil War in Stratford-Upon-Avon: Conflict and Community in South Warwicksh


£9.98


1992 F/U, 350th Anniv of the Civil War Set.


1992 F/U, 350th Anniv of the Civil War Set.


£0.75


Reprobates: The Cavaliers of the English Civil War John Stubbs


Reprobates: The Cavaliers of the English Civil War John Stubbs


£10.71


Bandits and Partisans: The Antonov Movement in the Russian Civil War Landis, Eri


Bandits and Partisans: The Antonov Movement in the Russian Civil War Landis, Eri


£44.12


Playmobil mixed  Civil War/Army selection


Playmobil mixed Civil War/Army selection


£3.00


VICTORIAN AMERICAN CIVIL WAR MALE CAMEO BROOCH IN PROFILE PINCHBECK FRAME


VICTORIAN AMERICAN CIVIL WAR MALE CAMEO BROOCH IN PROFILE PINCHBECK FRAME


£29.99


American Civil War historic US Treasury Department letter, 1864, USA, Union.


American Civil War historic US Treasury Department letter, 1864, USA, Union.


£12.00


Miniature Figurines (MINIFIGS) American Civil War Figures 25mm


Miniature Figurines (MINIFIGS) American Civil War Figures 25mm


£1.00


American Civil War bank check /cheque  signed NY Mayor Gunther! 1864


American Civil War bank check /cheque signed NY Mayor Gunther! 1864


£12.00


 SPAIN 1938 - MONTSERRAT- Civil War - Number A 015,747


SPAIN 1938 – MONTSERRAT- Civil War – Number A 015,747


£0.35


31 x 15mm Essex / Old Glroy Miniatures - American Civil War  Union / Reb Cavalry


31 x 15mm Essex / Old Glroy Miniatures – American Civil War Union / Reb Cavalry


£3.99


An Irishman in the Iron Brigade: The Civil War Memoirs of James P. Sullivan, Ser


An Irishman in the Iron Brigade: The Civil War Memoirs of James P. Sullivan, Ser


£51.65


GI JOE IDW #0 CVR C GI JOE COBRA CIVIL WAR NEW RARE


GI JOE IDW #0 CVR C GI JOE COBRA CIVIL WAR NEW RARE


£0.99


Commanding Boston's Irish Ninth: The Civil War Letters of Colonel Patrick R. Gui


Commanding Boston’s Irish Ninth: The Civil War Letters of Colonel Patrick R. Gui


£32.31


The Limits of Dissent: Clement L. Vallandigham & the Civil War Frank L. Klement


The Limits of Dissent: Clement L. Vallandigham & the Civil War Frank L. Klement


£36.27


New Masters: Northern Planters During the Civil War and Reconstruction Lawrence


New Masters: Northern Planters During the Civil War and Reconstruction Lawrence


£51.65


A Grand Terrible Dramma: From Gettysburg to Petersburg - The Civil War Letters o


A Grand Terrible Dramma: From Gettysburg to Petersburg – The Civil War Letters o


£52.49


Glass/Wilson: The Civil Wars


Glass/Wilson: The Civil Wars


£10.00


Soldiers of Peace: Civil War Pacifism and the Postwar Radical Peace Movement Tho


Soldiers of Peace: Civil War Pacifism and the Postwar Radical Peace Movement Tho


£46.61


Sacred Debts: State Civil War Claims and American Federalism, 1861-1880 Kyle S.


Sacred Debts: State Civil War Claims and American Federalism, 1861-1880 Kyle S.


£51.00


Emma Spaulding Bryant: Civil War Bride, Carpetbagger's Wife, Ardent Feminist : L


Emma Spaulding Bryant: Civil War Bride, Carpetbagger’s Wife, Ardent Feminist : L


£75.92


Emma Spaulding Bryant: Civil War Bride, Carpetbagger's Wife, Ardent Feminist; Le


Emma Spaulding Bryant: Civil War Bride, Carpetbagger’s Wife, Ardent Feminist; Le


£24.81


Freedom, Union, and Power: Lincoln and His Party During the Civil War Michael S.


Freedom, Union, and Power: Lincoln and His Party During the Civil War Michael S.


£65.93


The North and the Nation in the ERA of the Civil War (The North's Civil War, 25)


The North and the Nation in the ERA of the Civil War (The North’s Civil War, 25)


£51.65


Busy Hands: Images of the Family in the Northern Civil War Effort Richard, Patri


Busy Hands: Images of the Family in the Northern Civil War Effort Richard, Patri


£47.26


Yours for the Union: The Civil War Letters of John W. Chase, First Massachusetts


Yours for the Union: The Civil War Letters of John W. Chase, First Massachusetts


£57.25


Yours for the Union: The Civil War Letters of John W. Chase, First Massachusetts


Yours for the Union: The Civil War Letters of John W. Chase, First Massachusetts


£23.21


Fear Was Not in Him: The Civil War Letters of Major General Francis C. Barlow, U


Fear Was Not in Him: The Civil War Letters of Major General Francis C. Barlow, U


£56.65





“Fear Was Not in Him”: The Civil War Letters of Major General Francis C. Barlow,


£20.26


The Civil War Confiscation Acts: Failing to Reconstruct the South Syrett, John


The Civil War Confiscation Acts: Failing to Reconstruct the South Syrett, John


£24.51


Another Civil War: Labor, Capital, And the State in the Anthracite Regions of Pe


Another Civil War: Labor, Capital, And the State in the Anthracite Regions of Pe


£15.37


L456 LOT OF 2 FRAMED CIVIL WAR PHOTOGRAPHIC PRINTS ROBERT E. LEE


L456 LOT OF 2 FRAMED CIVIL WAR PHOTOGRAPHIC PRINTS ROBERT E. LEE


£0.63


Chancellorsville and the Germans: Nativism, Ethnicity, and Civil War Memory Kell


Chancellorsville and the Germans: Nativism, Ethnicity, and Civil War Memory Kell


£23.06


FIRST DAY COVER - THE CIVIL WAR 1992 - UNADDRESSED


FIRST DAY COVER – THE CIVIL WAR 1992 – UNADDRESSED


£1.50


The Doom of Reconstruction: The Liberal Republicans in the Civil War Era Slap, A


The Doom of Reconstruction: The Liberal Republicans in the Civil War Era Slap, A


£34.20


Del Prado Spanish Civil War WW2 Italian Officer Marshal Alpini 1937 1/32


Del Prado Spanish Civil War WW2 Italian Officer Marshal Alpini 1937 1/32


£11.99


A Philadelphia Perspective: The Civil War Diary of Sidney George Fisher Fisher,


A Philadelphia Perspective: The Civil War Diary of Sidney George Fisher Fisher,


£25.75


Their Patriotic Duty: The Civil War Letters of the Evans Family of Brown County,


Their Patriotic Duty: The Civil War Letters of the Evans Family of Brown County,


£36.39


Civil War America: Voices from the Home Front Marten, James Alan


Civil War America: Voices from the Home Front Marten, James Alan


£25.75


The American Civil War A Military History Book | John K


The American Civil War A Military History Book | John K


£10.22


RENAISSANCE PIRATE CELTIC WENCH CIVIL WAR PEASANT COSTUME WHITE GOWN DRESS  #Cd2


RENAISSANCE PIRATE CELTIC WENCH CIVIL WAR PEASANT COSTUME WHITE GOWN DRESS #Cd2


£34.79


TUPOLEV SB 2 M-100 KATIUSHKA - SPANISH CIVIL WAR 1/72 ICM


TUPOLEV SB 2 M-100 KATIUSHKA – SPANISH CIVIL WAR 1/72 ICM


£13.99


L486 CIVIL WAR PHOTOS JEB STUART TUNIC & FLAG, UNION GENERALS GRANT, RAWLINGS +


L486 CIVIL WAR PHOTOS JEB STUART TUNIC & FLAG, UNION GENERALS GRANT, RAWLINGS +


£0.63


Deserter Country: Civil War Opposition in the Pennsylvania Appalachians (North's


Deserter Country: Civil War Opposition in the Pennsylvania Appalachians (North’s


£51.00


The Causes of the Civil War Book | Kenneth M. Stampp NE


The Causes of the Civil War Book | Kenneth M. Stampp NE


£9.45

Guns n Roses Civil war live (Voodoo Child intro)

Civil War AMAZON PRODUCTS BELOW


PROPAGANDA LE GUERRA CIVIL POSTER * Spanish Civil War HIGH QUALITY 250gsm GLOSS ART CARD A3 Reproduction Print


PROPAGANDA LE GUERRA CIVIL POSTER * Spanish Civil War HIGH QUALITY 250gsm GLOSS ART CARD A3 Reproduction Print


£5.99


A3 * 29.7 x 42cm * 297 x 420mm *…

THE INTERNATIONAL BRIGADE SPANISH CIVIL WAR A3 SIZE GLOSSY POSTER PRINT


THE INTERNATIONAL BRIGADE SPANISH CIVIL WAR A3 SIZE GLOSSY POSTER PRINT


£4.99


PRINT ON DEMAND POSTER (UNFRAMED) GLOSSY POSTER 165 gm PAPERN A3 SIZE: 420 x 297 mm 16.5 x 11.7 in…

PROPAGANDA LE GUERRA CIVIL POSTER * Spanish Civil War HIGH QUALITY 250gsm GLOSS ART CARD A3 Reproduction Print


PROPAGANDA LE GUERRA CIVIL POSTER * Spanish Civil War HIGH QUALITY 250gsm GLOSS ART CARD A3 Reproduction Print


£5.99


A3 * 29.7 x 42cm * 297 x 420mm *…

Barton Hollow


Barton Hollow


£7.33



Use Your Illusion II


Use Your Illusion II


£3.99


titolo-use your illusions 2artista-guns n’ roses etichetta-geffen recordsn. dischi1data11 settembre 1991supportocd audiogenerehard rock e metal—-brani1.civil warascolta2.14 yearsascolta3.yesterdaysascolta4.knockin’ on heaven’s doorascolta5.get in the ri…

Barton Hollow


Barton Hollow


£6.74


STANDARD EDITION : Debut 2011 album! Organic folk-pop ‘n’ rootsy harmonics from the Nashville duo, for fans of Swell Season and Gillian Welch….

THE SCAVENGERS (1969) - Jonathan Bliss


THE SCAVENGERS (1969) – Jonathan Bliss



The Scavengers Were Rotten to the Core – Thoroughly Disgusting, And Had a Serious Freudian Problem… You’ll Probably Love Them…


Great Crimes and Trials of the 20th Century Vol. 14 - Rise of the Mafia / Ku Klux Klan (Video Tape/PAL) 1993


Great Crimes and Trials of the 20th Century Vol. 14 – Rise of the Mafia / Ku Klux Klan (Video Tape/PAL) 1993


£12.99


Rise of the Mafia – Originating as a resistance movement against Arab invaders in 9th Century Sicily, this secret society was brought to the United States during the great waves of emigration from Italy in the late 19th Century. It was soon organising crime and racketeering in many American cities, and under bosses like ‘Lucky’ Luciano , Carlo Gambino and Santo Trafficante became a nationwide busi…

American Civil War Vol.1 [VHS]


American Civil War Vol.1 [VHS]


£17.00



Civil War, A NATION DIVIDED


Civil War, A NATION DIVIDED




  • admin (533)
  • Leave a Reply